Come on guys, be serious. Would you like to see your own grandmother being
managed by a mobile service robot? Can you imagine getting old yourself:
one day will be your last and just by accident the last thing you
see happens to be a dumb robot.
Yes, even if it had web-2.0 features and even if it had
a webcam so that you can log in remote and have a chat with your grandparents
lying down in bed. There is
so much research about robots and every now and then I get to read something
like this:
In particular, robots that could serve as personal assistants for people -- especially those who are elderly or physically challenged -- are moving from fantasy to the realm of the possible. The rapid progress in computing and the growing body of knowledge in robotics are leading us toward a goal which could have many benefits for society. (link)
As much as I admire the success in this area, like
this ball bot, that
balances on a ball to move in all directions, I must say: Did anybody ever
ask any grandmom or granddad if he would appreciate having one at home?
I guess this has not happened because the answer would be deflating.
So why are researchers saying so all the time that mobile robots
will have ``may benefits for society''? I seriously doubt that. Have you
ever read any science fiction story where those kind of robots did
not
end up being a nightmare. Hello this is earth calling. Please fix Internet
Explorer first and admit that 3D desktops and all this other stuff really
does not work out. And I am talking about today, not about any horror fantasy
escaping from imagination to reality.
Research is not client-driven
but driven by interests ... well and project funding. At any time there is
a certain round dance in project lyrics where you have to trigger a set
of buzz words meeting the hype. But this ``elderly people being served
by mobile robots'' stanza is disgusting. Repeating it does not improve it.
While industrial robots have their place in automation
to avoid human interactions, this is no valid criterion for geriatrics
or parenting. That's where
more human interaction is needed, even if
it is difficult to stand balky grannies.